Skip to content

Article

I Tried to be Someone Else and Failed as a Leader Because of it

By Teena Sauve2 min read
Cover image for “I Tried to be Someone Else and Failed as a Leader Because of it”

I thought I had to be a certain type of person to be a successful leader.

About 25 years ago, when I moved into my first management role, I had the opportunity to complete a DiSC assessment. When they described a D type, I felt like that was what I had to be as a leader. I thought that all leaders had to be direct and results-driven, and well, not really. I don’t really know how to explain it, that dominant style was just what I thought leaders had to be. All the leaders I had experienced had an “I’ll tell you what to do, you do it, or I fire you” management style. When I first completed the DiSC assessment all those years ago, it was on paper and I was able to answer the questions in a way that would drive out that D style.

When I left the corporate environment and started Botree, I missed having those resources around me and decided to take the DiSC assessment. When I did the test, I got the result of “I”, which is the influence style. I was shocked. I remember calling the company and telling them that my results were wrong. So I did it again. Same results. Then I did the Wiley DiSC Assessment. Still an I.

That’s when it hit me. Reading all the information about the I style, it all started to make sense to me. I remember thinking “Oh my goodness, I’ve always been this person.” I mean, there’s no hard evidence about it, but I do believe that is the reason I struggled with leading a team for a long time in my early years. I was trying to lead in a way that didn’t come naturally to me. It wasn’t authentic. I look back and I think I was a bit of a fraud of a manager because I wasn’t being me.

Once I came to terms with my “I” style, I was able to learn skills to help me lead a team while still being “me”. Now that I am comfortable in my own skin, I can see the value I bring as a leader and accept the things that don’t come naturally to me. As an “I” style leader, I care a lot about people. It’s my greatest strength, and probably my biggest weakness as well. By trying to be something that wasn’t inherent to me, I was constantly pulling myself and exhausting myself to fit somewhere that I wasn’t meant to be. I couldn’t be the best version of myself, because I wasn’t even being myself to begin with.

It doesn't necessarily matter what your type is. I think a lot of people think a certain way or a certain style is better suited than others for leadership. That’s not the case. We are all a mixture of all the DiSC styles and each style brings its own benefits to a team. Having that understanding of your authentic self, and being comfortable with it, makes you a better leader. Knowing where your limitations are, what you’re passionate about, helps. Knowing my authentic leadership style has allowed me to show up in a really optimal way for my clients and my team.

See all
  • What Happens When Leaders Commit to 24 Weeks of Leveling-Up.

    We are living through one of the most significant shifts in leadership our generation has ever seen. New technologies, ever-changing workforce expectations, hybrid culture, global uncertainty… everything is evolving at record speed. “The rate of change affecting businesses has risen steadily since 2019, increasing by 183% over the past four years and by 33% in 2024 alone.

    By Botree Team13 min read
  • The $100,000-a-Day Mistake Your Company Might Be Making

    Remember tornado drills in school? Or fire drills at work? At the time, they probably felt tedious interruptions to a productive day (or - in school - probably a fun little trip out to the hall). But imagine if those drills didn’t exist. The alarm goes off. No one knows where to go. People panic. Some ignore it. Some run the wrong way. And in the confusion? What could have been controlled becomes costly both financially and, more importantly, physically.

    By Sylvie Carr3 min read

Ready to build a stronger team?

Tell us where your team is today and where you'd like it to be. We'll help you plan the way there.

Get in touch